Lightning Speed Laminates: Optimizing Thermal Management for Wireless Communication Systems

The term wireless communication has been around for many years, and it can mean many different things. The wireless communication between your mouse and your computer is very different than the wireless communication between a satellite and its ground station. The PCBs which are used for wireless communications are as diverse as the term. As a general statement, a more complex wireless communication system will require a more complex PCB.

Depending on the wireless system, the requirements for the PCB can be diverse. Even within a system, the different modules or components can have very different requirements. A good example of a complex wireless communication system would be an application for a LEO (Low Earth Orbit) satellite system. The ground station will have different requirements than the space-based station. Two major differences between these two components are power level and power management.

The satellite will be designed to be very efficient for the use of electric power, due to the normal limits of operating in space. The ground station is typically less concerned with power management and can offer much higher power levels than the satellite, although with higher power levels will usually come tradeoffs between thermal management and system performance.

The satellite systems will have concerns with thermal management, but often different than the concerns for thermal management of the ground station electronics. The thermal management issues for the ground station PCBs are usually focused around using high-frequency circuit materials with low loss, high thermal conductivity, low CTE (coefficient of thermal expansion), and low TCDk (thermal coefficient of Dk). The PCB design and fabrication are also considered for thermal management concerns and, when practical, design features like via farms or via fences are included.

Most dielectrics used for high-frequency circuit materials have poor thermal conductivity when compared to the excellent thermal conductivity of metals. As a simple comparison, the thermal conductivity of copper is about 400 W/m∙K and most PCB dielectric materials have a thermal conductivity around 0.3 W/m∙K. Because of the big difference in thermal conductivity, some PCBs with thermal management challenges will have cavities built into them, which will minimize the amount of dielectric material in the heat flow path. The heat flow path originates from the heat source that resides on the PCB or a RF trace on the circuit, and the migration of that heat to a heat sink that will absorb the heat.

Over many years of dealing with thermal management issues, the PCB industry has informally adopted a rule of thumb that a dielectric with thermal conductivity of 0.5 W/m∙K or higher is considered good for thermal management concerns. Many of the ceramic-filled high-frequency laminates have this thermal conductivity value or higher but there are a few special materials with significantly higher thermal conductivity.

RF designers must consider the different properties of the high-frequency circuit materials used in the board. For thermal management issues, a thicker substrate will increase the heat flow path, and that is not desirable. However, a thicker laminate is often desired when operating at lower microwave frequencies because there will be less insertion loss. This assumes the use of a low-loss material, with a low dissipation factor. Insertion loss is directly related to heat generation due to RF power heating the circuit, and higher insertion loss will cause more heat to be generated. A thin circuit will have a shorter heat flow path and that is desired for good thermal management. However, a circuit using a thinner substrate will have higher insertion loss and more heated generated from the applied RF power.

The tradeoffs for thermal conductivity are described here, but an application using a thick substrate should consider a material with high thermal conductivity and low dissipation factor. Of course, an application using a thin substrate will also benefit from these properties, but typically more attention is put on minimizing insertion loss so there is less heat generated. In minimizing insertion loss for a circuit based on a thin substrate, copper surface roughness is often a consideration.

Copper surface roughness at the substrate-copper interface can have significant impact on insertion loss and that is especially true for circuits based on thinner substrates. A rougher copper surface will increase conductor loss and conductor loss is usually a large portion of the overall insertion loss for a circuit based on thin material. Basically, when the copper planes are close together, which is the case for a circuit using a thin substrate, the effects of the copper surfaces will be more impactful on RF performance. The effects on RF performance are related to phase angle, wave velocity, effective Dk and, as already stated, insertion loss.

An example of material formulated specifically for thermal management concerns is a laminate with a thermal conductivity value of 1.24 W/m∙K, considered very good for this property, designed for high-frequency circuit materials. Additionally, the laminate has a low dissipation factor of 0.0017 and is available with a very low-profile copper offering a smooth copper surface. Another property not previously mentioned but that can be significant for thermal management, is moisture absorption. The moisture absorption for this laminate is extremely low at 0.05% and that will greatly minimize the undesired effects that moisture can have on RF performance.

There are several different test methods which can be used to determine the thermal conductivity of a substrate. We always use a test method that does not include the effects of copper, so the stated thermal conductivity of the laminate is that of the substrate only. There are other suppliers of high-frequency laminates, which will include the effects of copper in their testing for thermal conductivity and that will cause the property to appear much better than is actually true of the substrate. For this reason and many others mentioned, it is always good to contact your material supplier when working on a new design that is sensitive to thermal issues.

This column originally appeared in the April 2023 issue of Design007 Magazine.



Lightning Speed Laminates: Optimizing Thermal Management for Wireless Communication Systems


The term wireless communication has been around for many years, and it can mean many different things. The wireless communication between your mouse and your computer is very different than the wireless communication between a satellite and its ground station. The PCBs which are used for wireless communications are as diverse as the term. As a general statement, a more complex wireless communication system will require a more complex PCB.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Test Vehicles for PCB Electrical Material Characterization


Electrical characterization of high frequency circuit materials can be done in a variety of ways. Some characterization methods use a fixture to test the raw dielectric material, while other methods use circuits. The Dk and Df results shown on material data sheets are commonly obtained by a fixture test method. However, when comparing results from circuit evaluations, the Dk results from the fixture tests occasionally do not agree with the Dk results of the circuit tests. The reasons for these differences vary and are often situation-dependent. In general, however, the variables that impact the Dk extraction differ between a fixtured test method and a circuit test.

View Story


Lightning Speed Laminates: Optimum Thermal Stability Considerations


As technology advances, thermal expectations are becoming more critical, and designers need to be aware of the many different aspects that can alter the performance of a circuit due to thermal issues. Thermal concerns can be different for digital applications versus RF applications, and when DC or AC power is included, they can further complicate the matter.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Thermal Management Isn’t Getting Easier


From my perspective, thermal management continues to get more complicated as applications become more complex. Even applications at millimeter-wave frequencies, which typically use lower power, also have thermal management issues. It is a large topic, and this article will focus on practical issues related to PCB design and construction. To start, heat can be generated for a circuit application in a variety of ways. Sometimes the heat is generated from an active device, sometimes it is generated from the resident power within the PCB, sometimes the heat source is from the operating environment and sometimes it is a mix of these issues. It is easier to deal with thermal management if you take one issue at a time.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Benefits of High-Performance Hybrid Multilayer PCBs


A hybrid multilayer PCB is a circuit consisting of several layers of different circuit materials. This is typically done for cost reasons, but there are other reasons as well. Sometimes using a combination of different materials in a circuit stackup can assist with adjusting the overall coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of the circuit and that can be advantageous for circuit assembly and reliability. Additionally, there have been different materials combined for hybrid circuits with the intent to impact thermal management, adjusting coupling and customizing electrical properties for different layers within the circuit. Another good reason for combining dissimilar materials for a hybrid multilayer circuit is to improve circuit fabrication.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: An Overview of Copper Foils


Copper foils used in the PCB industry are deceptively complex. Copper is an excellent electrical conductor and thermal conductor, which makes copper foil ideal for the conductive layers of most PCB applications. There are many other copper foil properties which are important for an engineer to understand. The copper foils used in the PCB industry are typically made as rolled wrought copper (rolled annealed copper or RA) or as electro-deposited (ED) copper.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: The Importance of Circuit Features for Millimeter-Wave Applications


Over the past several years there has been a steady increase in millimeter-wave (mmWave) applications. This was probably sparked by the chip industry which has the capability to produce chips in large volume, which have good mmWave performance. As the mmWave applications increased, most aspects of the electronics industry, including the PCB industry, were forced into a steep learning curve.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Prepreg Choices for Millimeter-wave PCB Applications


There are obviously a lot of prepreg choices in the PCB industry and in the past, it was common for the choice of prepreg to be dominated by PCB fabrication concerns. The prepreg’s which are used for high frequency or high-speed digital (HSD), address the same PCB fabrication concerns as much as possible, but also have other properties which are important for consistent high frequency or HSD performance.

View Story


Lightning Speed Laminates: 3D Printed High-Performance Circuitry


3D printing has been around for many years and as time has progressed, so has this technology. However, one aspect of 3D printing seems to have not been developed as much until recently. That aspect is related to the materials which are used for 3D printing and specifically, materials which are compatible with RF or high-speed digital (HSD) applications. There are many materials that can be used for 3D printing, but until recently, none of these materials had properties which were conducive to printing circuits with good RF or HSD performance.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Overview of Test Methods to Determine Material Dk and Df


There are many different test methods which can be used to determine the Dk (Dielectric constant or εr) and Df (Dissipation factor, Tan Delta, loss tangent) for circuit materials. IPC has 12 different test methods to determine Dk for materials.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: The Benefits of Understanding Engineering Disciplines for PCB Design


When a PCB designer understands the different aspects of PCB technology, they will certainly be able to deliver circuit designs that will be more robust and have better manufacturing yields. The high-volume manufacturing yields of a PCB are directly related to profit and that is the connection between good circuit design and a successful circuit-product.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Some ‘Exotic’ PCB Processes Could Become Commonplace


Technology is advancing quickly, however, due to technology demands, it is likely that some of the processes for PCB fabrication that have been previously considered exotic, may soon be considered commonplace. Columnist John Coonrod explains.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Using Simulation Software to Assist With PCB Design


There are many different types of simulation software on the market, which can be very helpful for the PCB designer. Each software has its own set of capabilities and limits. Understanding the basic attributes of the software can help a designer choose the appropriate software for their design task.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Things to Consider When Creating a Circuit Material Library


A circuit material library for the fabricator can be advantageous for multiple reasons. Sometimes these libraries are intended to be used for electrical predictions, such as impedance, insertion loss or other issues. Other times the information found in the circuit material libraries are used to assist with thermal issues, potential reliability concerns, circuit construction stackups and some processing issues.

View Story


Lightning Speed Laminates: Understanding Material Interactions With PCB Fab Processes


Having a good understanding of the circuit material that a designer is working with, along with the potential PCB fabrication influences, is essential for having a successful first-time evaluation of a new circuit design. John Coonrod explains how if a designer only considers the basic material properties of Dk and Df, that may not be enough information to have a successful first round of evaluations.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Why High-Frequency Materials Have Different Dk Values


When an engineer researches high-frequency circuit materials, they will notice there are many offerings of what appears to be the same material type but with different Dk values. John Coonrod gives a quick overview of the need for these materials with different Dk values, as related to different high-frequency applications.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Utilizing mmWave Technology to Optimize High-Speed Designs


For the past several years, John Coonrod has been working with many different millimeter-wave applications. In this column, he shares areas where understanding the tricks of mmWave technology could help improve design and performance for very high-speed digital technology.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: High-Frequency Circuit Material App Notes


High-frequency circuit materials are used in a variety of diverse applications. Due to this diversity, it is difficult to write an application (app) note for a specific high-frequency circuit material. John Coonrod explains while exploring Rogers Corporation's app notes.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Understanding Dk Data Key to Cost-aware Design


In the development stages of a circuit for a new PCB application, there are usually several iterations to the circuit. These many changes can be costly, and it is not uncommon for a project to have 4–8 changes before it can be released to the market. According to John Coonrod, one item that can substantially reduce the number of changes and the associated costs is the use of a good circuit simulation software.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: PCB Materials for High-power RF Applications


Most commercial PCB-based applications that use high power are typically associated with cellular base station technology; however, there are other applications. There are also several things to consider when working with high-power RF applications. John Coonrod focuses on PCB-based power amplifiers used in base station applications, but the basic concepts discussed here will apply to other high-power applications.

View Story


Lightning Speed Laminates: Test Vehicles for Materials Evaluation


There are many different types of PCB designs and constructions that can be used as a test vehicle to evaluate electrical properties. John Coonrod explains how a proper test vehicle to compare different circuit materials would be a design and construction that takes into consideration the different material properties and have the least amount of PCB fabrication variables that can impact the results.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Material Choices for 5G PCB Applications


The new 5G cellular infrastructure has many technological differences from previous infrastructures, which certainly impacts the PCBs and materials used to build these circuits. 5G applications are generally split up into two frequency bands; sub-6 GHz and millimeter-wave (mmWave). Most of the initial deployments for 5G technology will be based on the sub-6 GHz band of frequencies; however, there are already mmWave 5G systems, and in the future, there will be more.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Practical Evaluations of Glass Weave Effect


There are a few things to consider about glass weave effect. One point of interest is when a laminate is using more than one layer of glass, the glass weave effect is somewhat dampened due to an averaging effect of the glass weave layers with their random alignment to each other. Another point of interest would be when a conductor is much larger than the geometry of the glass bundles, knuckles, and open area. Then, the conductor will experience an averaging of these different Dk values from the glass weave effect. This is typically not a problem for electrical performance.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: How Copper Properties Impact PCB RF and High-speed Digital Performance


The circuit is a microstrip with a signal conductor on the top copper plane and a ground plane on the bottom of the circuit. Additionally, the concept of skin depth and wave propagation should be considered. Skin depth is the depth within the cross-sectional area of the copper where the majority of the RF current resides and is dependent on frequency. At lower frequencies, the RF current will have a thicker skin depth and use more of the conductor. At higher frequencies, the skin depth is thinner, and less of the conductor is used by the RF current.

View Story

Lightning Speed Laminates: Higher Frequencies Pave Way for Flexible Circuit Materials


The smaller wavelengths of mmWave frequencies tend to highlight circuit material anomalies at those higher frequencies—anomalies that can also influence the radio frequency (RF) performance of the circuit. Such material anomalies include variations in dielectric thickness, dielectric constant (Dk), copper conductor width and spacing, and copper conductor plated thickness. For mmWave circuits, even small variations in these key material properties can impact electrical performance. Fortunately, flexible circuit technology is typically well controlled for thickness compared to thicker, more rigid circuit board materials.

View Story
Copyright © 2023 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.